I say this with compassion, not with an air of judgment. I am not the world’s most confident woman (oh no, I assure you – and my husband will pipe in too – that I have my very own set of hang ups!), I just don’t have this body image problem. It’s not that I’m perfect or that I think I’m perfect. I just don’t care. The one who matters is happy with me and the One who created me made me the way I am. So I move on to other obsessions.
That said, I can’t help but be worried and concerned and, well, alarmed to sit down and notice just how rampant this body image issue is. What first got me thinking deeply about it was a book I read a year ago, Can’t Buy My Love: How Advertising Changes the Way We Think and Feel, by Jean Kilbourne (link goes to my review and summary). I leant it to a friend who later told me she had her husband read whole chapters of it, to see how she felt about her body and to understand the underlying reasons. I was shocked. She didn’t seem like the kind of person who would be – or should be – worried about her body! Then, just the other day, I found out that a dear, dear person has not been coming around us because she’s ten pounds overweight. Now, I know I’m a skinny Minnie, and the mistaken conclusion some even in my own family draw from that is that I’m one of the diet-obsessed types. But my husband is not (and I don’t say that to imply that he’s unattractive, or fat, or anything unappealing. I think he’s the hottest guy on the planet.). And we don’t care. I mean, we care that it’s important to people and we’re compassionate. But we don’t judge anyone on their weight or how they look.
And what has me really pondering today is the thought that it doesn’t matter how compassionate I am or the fact that I don’t care about how someone else looks. Their reality is found in their own perception, not in what I assure them (that I love them no matter how they look, that God loves them and created them that way, that it’s OK). There’s no convincing some of my girlfriends that they’re beautiful.
This afternoon, I told my husband that almost every woman I am friends with has some sort of body image issue. He looked at me with the look he gives me when he suspects me of making a gross exaggeration. Then he started naming names. Every single one of them was a “yup.” He was shocked; “So-and-so?!? Thus-and-such?!? They don’t have anything to worry about!” I’ve talked to many of my friends about this candidly. “Why?” I ask them. I’m curious. I want to know how to help them.
The range of answers is across the board. “I want to be healthier,” “I want to keep my husband’s attention,” “I want to lose that ten-twenty-etc pounds.” Some women have eating disorders that linger, and though they know about them, they struggle with them. Others just plain don’t like the way they look. At all.
I’m not bringing any of this up in the attitude of “good me, bad you.” I’m worried. This scares me in a way few things do. It makes me want to research and find out the root cause, though I suspect it’s not as simple as that.
This afternoon, my train of thought took a turn to my role as a mother. I thought about my two daughters. One of them is two, and is in the 98th or so percentile for weight. She’s pretty tall, and she’s solid as a brick wall. She’s a big kid for two. She’s probably going to be a big kid for three, and four, and seven, and twelve. The other one’s not born yet, but it’s possible she’ll be built just like her sister. And how long will it be before someone mentions that they’re fat? And how long before seeing the cartoons, the dolls in the stores, the infiltrations of society’s expectations of women’s bodies that they begin to obsess in the way that seems to be the norm?
Mothers, what do you do? I’m praying already. But I suspect it’s my example that’s going to set the bar, and something else. It’s the something else that I’m grappling with. It’s the cold fact of seeing every woman I know struggle with body image that has my blood alternately boiling with fury and freezing with fear for my girls.
I do think your friend who “wants to be healthier” has a good motivation. For me, it’s just fitting in my clothes. I used to be thin without trying and now the weight is creeping on, all in one spot…sigh…my husband does not mind–probably does not notice–but it does bother me.
I think we are all (myself included) our own worst enemies when it comes to how we look. Yes, advertising goes along with out body-image issues but I don’t think that’s the biggest one.
Can’t help you on the kid issue–my 3 are all slim, always have been–I think they’re all built to be runners like Big Brother.
As far as body image goes, I’m more upset with myself for lack of self control than what I actually look like. : (
For what I tell my daughters (one is “curvy” and one is skinny minny) stems from what I truly believe; God made us each different. Unique. Not one is better than the other, just different.
I think I’m with you in that “lack of body image” thing.
The prevalence of problems, though, in our society is just terrifying.
(I had more to say but I’ll post it at my own. :))
You’ve seen my skinny kids…and yet, I’ve heard them (even my BOYS) talk about being fat. I have intentionally not talked about my self-image in front of them, they don’t go off to school, they watch limited TV…and yet, it’s still there. Very scary.
I think it is challenging (for most of us) in our society to have a good self-image and to not fret about our weight or our hips, because I think it is difficult to actually live a healthy lifestyle. My grandpa could eat eggs and bacon for breakfast every morning, be tall and thin and live to his mid-70s without going to the gym! Something about being up before dawn to milk the cows, working in a steel mill all day (not at one of the desk jobs), and then coming home to do the rest of the farm chores.
Very few people have lives that active. And yet, the food they eat does not match their sedentary lifestyle. Donuts after Mass. Bagels at the office. McDonalds for lunch. Fast, easy pasta for supper. Plus, gluttony is acceptable in all it’s forms (being fat isn’t, but the vice is). So, our culture pressures us to supersize or snack or have a “fourth meal” (I just about died when I saw Taco Bell advertizing this over the summer), but then we are pressured to not show the effects of our excesses…hence the diets or the gym membership.
What to do? Have a good self-image (you’re already there), teach your child healthy eating habits, don’t talk about other people’s bodies (for good or bad) around your kids, if SHE talks about someone (my kids ask me if other women are pregnant too…yikes) then try to be upbeat in your response about how they look and how God made us all different. And ALWAYS tell her how beautiful she is…inside AND out (and mean it!).
And pray.
You know what I’m going to say!…
I think it’s the result of contraception culture. I think that body image issues for women are connected to how the opposite sex perceives them, even if girls/women aren’t consciously thinking about it. Back when the world was open to life by default (since contraception wasn’t widely available), society used to tell women and young girls that their value in our culture was related to the traits they’d ultimately need in marriage, and marriage went hand-in-hand with being a mother. So our culture valued traits like having good manners, being kind, loving, etc. and wasn’t so concerned with raw sexual appeal.
Now that having children is optional and marriage is seen as just about sexual monogamy (and sex is seen as primarily about pleasure), society tells women and young girls that their value is in being “hot”, basically in being a sexual object.
I know, it sounds like a stretch. But, based on my personal experience, (which I wrote about here), I really think that there’s a strong connection.
Also, I feel like I’ve noticed that in orthodox Catholic families where the children just assume that marriage and sex are about the creation of life, where they see that their mothers value their bodies more for the fact that their conduits for life and don’t make their #1 priority looking “young” or “sexy”, that girls in those families don’t seem to struggle with the same body issues that their peers do. (I could be wrong, just an observation.)
Sorry for rambling. 🙂