Soulless Creatures by Katharine Grubb

When author Katharine Grubb included me in an email asking me to review her newest novel, Soulless Creatures, I had two thoughts:




I’ve been a fan of Katharine’s writing since…well, it’s been quite a few years. And I couldn’t imagine why she was writing a horror novel, but I was all for reading it.

Even though my reading time was at a special low point, thanks to a certain vampire baby who sucked the life right out of me all. night. long. Even though I had a pile of review books. Even though…

…well, fiction is my passion, people. And I had some high expectations for this.



In the interest of celebrating Friday in true Quick Takes fashion, here are seven reasons Soulless Creatures by Katharine Grubb gets the Sarah Reinhard Coffee Cup of Approval (with a bit of baby drool on the edge, sorry) and why you will love it.

7 Reasons You'll Love Soulless Creatures - Sarah Reinhard Snoring Scholar

1. You’ll laugh. A lot.

Grubb’s bio reads, in part, that she is

a homeschooling mother of five, a novelist, a baker of bread, a comedian wannabe, a former running coward, PTSD survivor, and the author of Write A Novel In 10 Minutes A Day

Her Twitter feed (@10minnovelist) is always a hoot, and you can expect that and more in this novel.

2. It’s NOT a horror novel. At all.

Had I only paid attention to the book’s blurb, instead of just fawning over the author and my love of her, I would have realized this.

Working-class future leader Roy Castleberry and pampered over-thinker Jonathan Campbell are 18-year-old freshmen at the University of Oklahoma who think they know everything. Roy thinks Jonathan could succeed in wooing Abby if he stopped obsessing over Walden. Jonathan thinks Roy could learn to be self-actualized if he’d stop flirting with every girl he meets. They make a wager: if Roy can prove that he has some poetic thought, some inner life, A SOUL, then Jonathan will give him the car he got for graduation. Roy takes the bet because he thinks this is the easiest game he’s ever played. Roy spends the rest of the school year proving the existence of his soul, competing against Jonathan for Abby’s attention, dodging RAs who are curious about the fake ID ring in his room and dealing with his past. For Roy and Jonathan, college life in 1986 is richer, (both experientially and financially) than either of them expected.

3. If you grew up in the ’80s, you’ll have A Moment. Or maybe a few.

It was highly entertaining to read about the ’80s as if they happened over 30 years ago. Oh wait, they did.

They did?!?

I wasn’t in college in the ’80s, but I was kickin’ around in junior high and such. But oh, I relate.

And the phrases! The songs! The pop culture references woven throughout!

Go ahead. You know you want to.

4. It’s good, clean fun. And romance. And maybe some surprises too.

Grubb thinks big. And it comes across in her novels.

They’re packed with action and romance and great dialogue. But she never compromises. There’s a moral line she doesn’t cross…but they aren’t stuffy or stilted in any way.

It’s refreshing: great writing, big adventure, some sparks, and yet you don’t have to worry about smut or slips-of-the-tongue. (Not that I worry. But you know what I mean, right?)

5. The people are real. Maybe you even know them.

I’m a sucker for good characters. Again and again, when I’m trying to explain to people what I love about a book, I come back to characters as a strong selling point.

And, once again, I’m at that point. I was immersed in the plot and the story, and I was invested in the people she created. She had me there and she had me with them. They were people I got to know, who I was talking with in my head, who I cared about.

6. Yes, there’s a deep theme and a good message. But it’s fun to read!

There are some themes in Soulless Creatures that really challenged me, that made me look within myself and examine a bit.

Whether they were intended or not, I don’t know. But does it matter?

It’s terrible to read a novel with a theme that’s being pushed down your throat. But in the themes throughout this novel, Grubb never leaned on the easy road of preachiness. (She could’ve, too. Very, very easily.) Instead, she let her characters live their lives, make their mistakes, and live with the consequences (or not, as the case may be).

7. It’s an excellent book. Period.

Yep, this is the kind of book you’ll read and then pick back up later. Or share with your best friend. Or, better yet, BOTH. It’s equally popcorn reading and fiction that stretches you ever so much.

Highly recommended.

For more Quick Takes, be sure to visit Kelly at This Ain’t the Lyceum.